Workplace Safety at the “Tip of the Spear”: Lessons from the Australian Defence Force’s Recent Fine

A tragic incident involving a fatal gunshot wound in the Australian Defence Force (ADF) has highlighted the serious responsibilities of Persons Conducting a Business or Undertaking (PCBUs), especially those funded by public monies, to uphold the highest standards of health and safety—even in high-risk, frontline roles. This case serves as a stark reminder that no job, not even those “at the tip of the spear” in defence and public safety, is exempt from workplace safety obligations.

The incident led to a $220,000 fine for the ADF under the Work Health and Safety (WHS) Act after it was found to have failed in its duty of care to the individual involved. This case underscores the need for rigorous safety protocols, proper risk management, and accountability, particularly when workers operate in environments where the inherent risks are exceptionally high.

Attributes: RWN38, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons

The Incident: A Preventable Tragedy

The fatality occurred during a training exercise in which an ADF member sustained a gunshot wound to the head. While details of the specific circumstances surrounding the incident remain limited, the court ruling revealed that the ADF’s protocols fell short in several critical areas, particularly in managing the risks associated with live firearms and high-stakes scenarios.

For organisations like the ADF, where personnel face unique and extreme risks, rigorous safety protocols and adherence to WHS obligations are paramount. This tragedy underscores the necessity of not only recognizing the inherent dangers of such roles but also implementing systems to manage them effectively.

Safety Obligations of PCBUs in High-Risk Sectors

The ADF’s role as a PCBU, particularly one funded by public monies, places a significant onus on it to lead by example in terms of safety standards. All PCBUs are required to ensure, as far as reasonably practicable, that their workplaces are safe and free from health risks. This obligation extends even to extreme environments, such as defence training exercises, where hazards are often unavoidable but can be managed.

Key areas where PCBUs must demonstrate their commitment to safety include:

1. Rigorous Risk Assessment and Mitigation:

   - PCBUs must conduct thorough risk assessments for all activities, particularly those involving firearms, hazardous equipment, or high-risk environments. In this case, a more comprehensive evaluation of risks associated with firearms training could have identified and mitigated potential hazards.

   - Ongoing risk assessments, specific to the changing environments and conditions of training exercises, are essential to prevent tragic outcomes.

2. Clear and Effective Safety Protocols:

   - Effective safety protocols should dictate every aspect of high-risk activities, from equipment handling to emergency response. Given the life-and-death nature of defence training, such protocols must be strictly developed, communicated, and enforced.

   - In the case of the ADF, improved protocols regarding the safe handling of firearms and training practices could have contributed to preventing this fatal incident.

3. Adequate Training and Supervision:

   - Personnel engaged in dangerous activities must receive comprehensive training in both the operational and safety aspects of their roles. For defence roles, this includes training on equipment handling, situational awareness, and responding to potential safety breaches.

   - Supervisors should be thoroughly briefed on WHS obligations and trained to oversee high-risk activities with a focus on safety.

4. Accountability and Incident Review:

   - PCBUs must adopt a culture of accountability, where incidents are thoroughly reviewed and lessons are learned. This includes conducting detailed investigations to uncover underlying issues and implementing necessary changes to prevent recurrence.

   - The ADF’s response to this incident, including the review of training practices and protocols, should serve as an example for other high-risk organisations.

Public Accountability and Trust

As an organisation funded by public monies, the ADF has a heightened responsibility to the public not only to ensure the safety of its personnel but also to uphold trust. The government and public expect that institutions like the ADF, which operate with taxpayer support, will prioritize the welfare of their members by setting high standards for safety. Failing to meet these expectations not only puts lives at risk but also erodes public confidence.

In light of this incident, the $220,000 fine serves as more than just a financial penalty. It is a reminder that safety in publicly funded organisations is not just a legal obligation but a moral one, aimed at protecting those who put themselves in harm’s way.

#### Lessons for Other High-Risk PCBUs

The ADF’s case offers essential insights for other PCBUs operating in high-risk sectors, from construction to emergency services. The following lessons can help these organisations improve their safety practices:

1. Proactive Safety Culture:

   - PCBUs should foster a culture where safety is an integral part of every operation, not just a compliance requirement. Regular safety meetings, open communication channels, and visible commitment from leadership can reinforce the importance of safety at every level.

2. Continuous Improvement of Safety Practices:

   - High-risk environments are dynamic, requiring regular updates to safety protocols. PCBUs must be willing to reassess and adapt their safety practices, particularly in response to incidents or near-misses.

3. Involving Workers in Safety Planning:

   - Workers on the ground often have the best insights into potential risks. Including them in safety planning and risk assessments can ensure that WHS measures address the realities of the work environment.

4. Investing in WHS Training and Resources:

   - WHS is an ongoing commitment that requires adequate funding and resources. Publicly funded organisations, in particular, should invest in the latest training, equipment, and technologies to keep their personnel safe.

Safety Beyond Compliance

The tragic incident in the ADF’s training exercise serves as a reminder that workplace safety, even in the most hazardous roles, must be prioritized above all else. PCBUs, particularly those funded by the public, have an obligation to protect their workers and to set a standard that reflects both legal and moral responsibility. The $220,000 fine underscores the critical nature of these obligations, emphasizing that safety must be built into every level of planning and execution.

By fostering a proactive safety culture, engaging in continuous improvement, and upholding accountability, high-risk organisations can help prevent such devastating incidents and honour the trust placed in them by the public and the people they employ.